Arby’s Horsey Sauce

Jump to Recipe

Few fast-food sauces have built a cult following quite like Arby’s Horsey Sauce. Fans flock to its creamy, tangy kick that cuts through rich, hearty sandwiches—especially roast beef. If you’ve ever wished you could slather this sauce on homemade meals, the good news is that the magic comes together with staple ingredients in just minutes. Below, I’ll break down everything there is to know about Horsey Sauce, from its history and taste profile to prepping, storing, and using your own perfect batch at home.

What Makes Arby’s Horsey Sauce Iconic?

Horsey Sauce stands out with its unmistakable combination of creamy, sweet, and spicy. At its core, it’s a tangy horseradish-mayonnaise blend—smooth, spreadable, and versatile. The horseradish brings bite, the mayo adds balance, and a little sugar takes the edge off without dulling the character.

Horsey Sauce is more than a dip. Use it as a spread for sandwiches or wraps, swirl it through mashed potatoes, or drizzle it over grilled meats. This is the kind of condiment that can quickly become a kitchen staple.

Ingredients for Authentic Horsey Sauce

Surprisingly, you only need a few simple ingredients for this copycat version. Here’s what goes into a classic batch:

• Mayonnaise: Full-fat yields a lush texture, but low-fat varieties can work if you prefer. Homemade mayo brings even richer flavor.
• Prepared Horseradish: Creamy-style is best for smoothness, but regular works, too. Adjust to taste.
• Granulated Sugar: This helps moderate the heat of the horseradish and creates the signature mellow tang.
• Salt: Just a pinch brightens everything and underscores each flavor.

Optional additions: A tiny splash of white vinegar can sharpen the sauce; a bit of lemon juice delivers freshness.

Ingredient Pro Tips

• Horseradish: For extra heat, use freshly grated root (just reduce the quantity).
• Sweetener: You can swap sugar for honey or a sugar substitute, depending on your preference.
• Creaminess: Want a silkier finish? Add a teaspoon of sour cream or a small splash of heavy cream.
• Brand choice: Each brand of horseradish brings its own strength and texture. Taste and tweak as you go.

Ingredient Table

How to Make Arby’s Horsey Sauce

The process couldn’t be easier. With a whisk and a small bowl, you’ll have your sauce ready in under ten minutes.

Step-by-Step Instructions

• Measure ingredients
  Gather mayo, prepared horseradish, sugar, and salt. Place them in a small mixing bowl.

• Mix until smooth
  Whisk them together thoroughly. No lumps should remain; the sauce should have a glossy, even appearance.

• Taste and adjust
  Add more horseradish if you want extra heat, or a touch more sugar if you need to mellow the bite.

• Rest for flavor
  For the most developed taste, cover and chill for at least 30 minutes. This lets the flavors meld.

Visual Guide

Tips for the Best Homemade Horsey Sauce

Mastering this sauce comes down to balancing taste and texture. Here’s how to fine-tune your batch.

• Horseradish heat: The spiciness depends on the freshness and strength of the horseradish. If using fresh, start with less, taste, then add more.
• Consistency control: For a thinner, drizzling sauce, add a dash of water or milk. For a thicker spread, use less horseradish.
• No prepared horseradish? Grate fresh horseradish root and combine with a splash of white vinegar. This unlocks its signature heat.
• Extra flavor: Blend in a teaspoon of Dijon or yellow mustard for depth.
• Salad dressing twist: Add a touch of vinegar and a drizzle of olive oil to transform it into a zesty salad topper.

How to Store and Serve

Storing Your Sauce

• Refrigeration: Always store Horsey Sauce in an airtight jar or container. It keeps well in the fridge for up to two weeks.
• Do not freeze: Freezing changes the sauce’s texture, making it watery and separating its ingredients.
• Batch prep: Make double batches for parties and keep extra on hand—it never lasts long.

Serving Ideas

Horsey Sauce shines in plenty of settings:

• Classic roast beef sandwiches: The iconic combination that started it all.
• Spread for burgers and sliders: Balances rich beef or turkey patties.
• Dip for fries or onion rings: Try it alongside ketchup for a tasty twist.
• Drizzle on grilled vegetables: Asparagus, broccoli, or even sweet potatoes.
• Glaze for roasted meats: Pork loin, chicken, or even grilled fish.

Try mixing a little into mashed potatoes, or use as a zesty topping for baked potatoes and deviled eggs for a flavorful update.

All About Horseradish: The Heart of Horsey Sauce

Horseradish is a root vegetable related to mustard and wasabi. When grated, its cell walls break, releasing mustard oil compounds that create sharp heat. In sauces, horseradish brings a warming, nasal-tingling kick distinct from hot peppers’ fiery sensation.

Types of Horseradish

• Prepared horseradish: Grated and mixed with vinegar, found in jars.
• Cream-style horseradish: Contains dairy or mayonnaise for a milder, creamy texture.
• Fresh root: Pungent and potent, available in produce sections.

When shopping, keep in mind that horseradish strength fades with time. Always pick the freshest jar or root you can find.

Variations and Substitutions

Every cook puts a spin on classic sauces. Here are common variations and tweaks:

• Wasabi substitute: In a pinch, blend a small bit of wasabi paste into the mix for a similar nose-tingling heat.
• Mustard addition: A teaspoon of English or Dijon mustard layers in more complex flavor.
• Reduced fat: Light mayonnaise and sugar substitutes work well for those tracking calories.
• Dairy-free: Choose vegan mayo varieties for a plant-based version.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)

Is Horsey Sauce spicy?
It has a sharp bite from horseradish, but the mayonnaise and sugar mellow it, creating a pleasant warmth instead of strong heat.

Can I use Miracle Whip instead of mayonnaise?
Yes, though the taste will be sweeter and tangier.

How do I adjust the heat?
Add more or less horseradish. Cream-style horseradish is milder, while straight prepared or fresh-grated is bolder.

How long does homemade Horsey Sauce last?
Up to two weeks in the fridge if sealed well.

Horsey Sauce is more than a fast-food treat—it’s a go-anywhere condiment that fits almost any meal where you crave tang and heat. Making it at home takes just a few staple ingredients and less than ten minutes. The moment you taste it—smoothed over roast beef, dabbed onto fries, or spooned into a wrap—you’ll wonder why you ever chased down those tiny packets. With this recipe, you’re never far from the bold flavors you love. Enjoy experimenting and making Horsey Sauce your new kitchen workhorse.